“promote a good and righteous American culture in which spiritually-primed but morally vacuous Indians can come to know Christ”

We can’t even do that for our own people. If we’re going to expend that kind of effort, let’s use it on taking the spec out of own eye first.

As for rubbish disposal in India, that is less a product of poor civics (although it definitely is that to some degree) or poor engineering (and is that too, although India has a moderately successful space program). It’s more a legacy of the caste system – jobs for the untouchable or unclean, or in a more progressive modern sense an opportunity given to those at the bottom of the socio-economic ladder to make some kind of livelihood from waste, which has an entire economy of its own. Rubbish that accumulates on the street is simply the stuff left over that no-one can use. In a massively overpopulated country, with a strong legacy of caste and a highly stratified economy, it’s hard to keep everyone gainfully employed. This is why India is so confusing to the West. The notion of progress that needs strong civics and quality people is secondary to a culture that considers all paths to God as valid, even the paths of the unrich, unclean and unrighteous. To each his own and that’s their lot, that sort of thing.

As for Indian immigrants, if H1B’s are being handed out to low-grade workers who are accepted because they’re willing to work cheap, then that’s what they will be. That’s not their fault. They’re simply accepting what the host nation is giving them. They’re not cultural or economic parasites like those in the Levant who America loves to support with $billions, but morally vacuous spiritualists who need a good and righteous container. If the host culture is a good and righteous one, Indians will fill that container. If it’s neither good nor righteous, as in the FUSA, then they will simply become India wherever they land since that’s the default setting.

The real problem here is that Indians are scattering abroad in vast numbers on the jet streams of technological change while Team America World Police militarizes the Western world into demographic and financial poverty for the right to be morally degenerate. The West has turned itself into a moral vacuum and India is pouring herself comfortably into it. That, again, is not the fault of Indians. That is the fault of Americans, who have allowed their nation to fall into degeneracy.

The solution to the problem is a lot simpler than what you’ve proposed in this letter to Musk. None of that is going to happen as you well know. Other prominent bloggers on the internet blow the 1965 Hart-Celler Act repeal nonsense up their smokestack every other day knowing full well that it’s unworkable.

There are only two possible solutions: one, implement race-based selection on immigration, or two, promote a good and righteous American culture in which spiritually-primed but morally vacuous Indians can come to know Christ (which needs only a bible and a desire to read it.) Only one of these is consistent with Biblical values.

This is of course with the proviso that any and all foreign foreign women brought into this nation for such morale and genetic improvement purposes be subject to an entirely different family law code. Divorce for any reason (save provable adultery) will result in the woman’s immediate deportation from the USA. Citizenship will not be granted to foreign women until she has reached her sixties.