When I come to power, sir, I'll be calling you up to see if you're interested in the position of Chief Inquisitor. With full powers to carry out public crucifixions and an army of well-trained excruciators, of course.

With respect to the "proposition" part, sir, I think you make a good point.

From what I have seen of America and its people, to be "American" requires accepting, at a very fundamental level, the founding principles of America: freedom as the substitution of internally rather than externally imposed discipline, adherence to and acceptance of an ultimately Christian code of morality, and a keen fear and loathing of overbearing government. There is obviously quite a bit more to it than just these things, but that is what I would consider a starting point for what it means to be "American".

The problem for the "magic dirt" types is that most of the "huddled masses yearning to breathe free" will completely fail to agree with any of these propositions when examined closely.

Ultimately the "proposition" of America is a worldview that is quite unique, and which binds the people of this country together- a belief in an actual, geographically and culturally distinct nation called America. But a nation, by definition, cannot also be "magic dirt".

And that's one of the areas where Vox and I differ. I've stated my position on VP often enough that there's no sense in going after it every day. I'd end up doing nothing else. But there is a difference, an important one and true, between magic dirt theory / proposition nation, which means, as practiced, a 100% proposition nation, and a real nation that has some element of proposition to it. I'm pretty sure Vox understands the difference but is engaged in rhetoric for the benefit of the great unwashed.

Well that presumes that there are enough whites around with the will and the means to take things back. That's going to increasingly become a challenge as whites become a racial minority in their own land.

"Magic Dirt" theory is rapidly running out of credibility. I don't think it will be too long before whites start gunning up in sufficient numbers that black predation upon them will become more dangerous for the predators than their intended prey.

When that happens… look out below.